The Best Pizza Slices in New York 🍕
The Best Pizza Slices in New York 🍕
Tom Isbister
Available for hire
Discover the tastiest pizza slices in New York City! From classic thin-crust at Joe’s Pizza to coal-fired perfection at Lombardi’s, NYC is a haven for pizza lovers.
Whether you are a lifelong New Yorker or a first-time visitor, our ultimate NYC pizza guide will satisfy your cravings and help you experience the city's culinary soul one slice at a time. These pizza hotspots are a must-visit on your New York journey, perfect for quick bites, late-night cravings, or foodie adventures.
Save this guide and find a slice of New York pizza for yourself!
Updated ago
7
Share
🗺️ Google Maps Version
⭐ Top Rated
⭐ Scarr's Pizza
@TbisTer
If you're hunting for one of NYC's top pizza slices, Scarr's Pizza on the Lower East Side is a must-visit. Known for its retro vibes and serious dedication to quality, Scarr's serves up incredible pies made with freshly milled flour (yes, they mill it on-site!). Their thin, crispy crust strikes the perfect balance between chewy and crunchy, and the cheese-to-sauce ratio is spot-on.
What to Order: Start with the classic cheese slice—it’s simple but absolutely flawless. If you’re feeling adventurous, their Sicilian slice is also a crowd favorite.
Add to
Details
⭐ Joe's Pizza Broadway
@TbisTer
Joe’s Pizza on Broadway is a classic New York City spot for no-frills, authentic pizza. A staple since 1975, this place is all about perfecting the traditional New York-style slice. With its thin, foldable crust, tangy sauce, and just the right amount of cheese, it’s the quintessential NYC pizza experience.
What to Order: Go for the plain cheese slice—it’s simple, iconic, and exactly what Joe’s is famous for.
Joe’s is cash only, so come prepared. Expect a line, especially during peak hours, but it moves quickly and is 100% worth the wait.
Add to
Details
⭐ L'Industrie Pizzeria
@TbisTer
L’Industrie Pizzeria in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is a slice shop that’s taken NYC’s pizza scene by storm. Known for its ultra-thin crust and high-quality, fresh ingredients, it’s a spot where tradition meets innovation.
What to Order: The Burrata Slice is the star here, topped with creamy burrata cheese, fresh arugula, and a drizzle of balsamic glaze. For purists, the plain cheese slice is equally outstanding, with a perfectly charred crust and a savory tomato sauce that stands out.
Add to
Details
⭐ Prince Street Pizza
@TbisTer
When it comes to bold, crave-worthy slices, Prince Street Pizza is a New York institution. Famous for its thick, square-shaped Spicy Spring slice, this spot delivers a serious flavor punch with crispy, caramelized edges, tangy marinara, gooey mozzarella, and perfectly spicy pepperoni cups.
The slices are aesthetically pleasing and perfect for that iconic Instagram post.
What to Order: The Spicy Spring is a must-try, but if you’re not into spice, their classic square slice is equally satisfying.
Add to
Details
⭐ Lucia Pizza Of Avenue X
@TbisTer
If you’re craving standout pizza, Lucia Pizza and its two locations hit the spot. This cash-only, old-school, no-frills pizzeria has been serving up incredible slices for decades, earning a loyal fan base. It’s the definition of a classic New York slice: a thin, foldable crust with the perfect amount of sauce and a gooey layer of cheese.
What to Order: The regular cheese slice is the star here—simple, satisfying, and perfectly executed. If you’re hungry, go for the hearty Sicilian slice with its thick, airy crust and flavorful tomato sauce.
Add to
Details
⭐ Lucia Pizza Of SoHo
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
⭐ Best Pizza
@TbisTer
If you’re in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, Best Pizza is a go-to spot that lives up to its name. This cozy, no-frills pizzeria combines old-school techniques with fresh, high-quality ingredients, creating slices that are simple yet unforgettable.
What to Order: The white slice is a standout—loaded with ricotta, caramelized onions, and sesame seeds on the crust. Of course, their classic cheese slice is a must-try too!
Add to
Details
⭐ New Park Pizza
@TbisTer
If you’re exploring New York’s pizza scene, New Park Pizza in Howard Beach, Queens, is a classic that’s worth the trip. This old-school spot has been slinging slices since the 1950s, and it’s famous for its perfectly charred crust, gooey cheese, and slightly sweet sauce.
What to Order: The classic cheese slice is a must—simple, timeless, and packed with flavor. Ask for it “well-done” to get that extra crispy edge on the crust.
Add to
Details
⭐ Paulie Gee's Slice Shop
@TbisTer
If you're in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, Paulie Gee's Slice Shop is the place to go for a slice that hits all the right notes. Unlike Paulie Gee’s main restaurant (known for its wood-fired pies), the Slice Shop is all about New York-style pizza served in a retro, no-frills setting.
What to Order: The classic Hellboy slice is a must-try, topped with spicy pepperoni and a drizzle of Mike’s Hot Honey—it’s sweet, spicy, and absolutely addictive. Their plain cheese and grandma slices are also fan favorites for good reason.
Add to
Details
⭐ Lombardi's Pizza
@TbisTer
If you're in the mood for classic New York pizza, Lombardi’s Pizza on Spring Street is the place to be. Known as America’s first pizzeria, this spot has been serving up delicious coal-oven pies since 1905. The crust is perfectly crispy with just the right amount of char, and the fresh mozzarella is top-notch. It’s a taste of pizza history in every bite!
What to Order: Their Margherita pizza is iconic, featuring a rich tomato sauce and high-quality mozzarella. If you’re craving something more hearty, their white pizza with ricotta and garlic is a winner.
Add to
Details
🍕 The List
Antonio's Pizza
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Brooklyn's Homeslice Pizza
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Ciccio’s Pizza
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Cuts & Slices
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Dani's House of Pizza
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Delmar Pizzeria
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Di Fara Pizza
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Franklin Pizza
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
J & V Pizzeria
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Krispy Pizza- Brooklyn, NY
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Lenny's Pizza
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Louie's
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Louie & Ernie's Pizza
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Luigi's Pizza
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Mama's TOO! Upper West Side
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
My Pie Pizzeria Romana
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
NY Pizza Suprema
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Patsy's Pizzeria
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Pronto Pizzeria
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Rizzo's Pizza
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Sal and Carmine Pizza
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Rosa's Pizza
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Sofia Pizza Shoppe
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Table 87
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
Williamsburg Pizza Lower East Side
@TbisTer
Add to
Details
📍 Check Out Our Other Guides
* * *
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Tom Isbister
Available for hire
Born from a passion for exploration, out of Toronto. Travel has taken me all over North America and Europe! I've gotten the opportunity to leave Canada, and live in Finland, Germany, and Poland. At the same time, having traveled to 18 countries!
From those opportunities, I started crafting and sharing my maps which I feel provide a sense of exploration and recommendations that others can use to create their own memorable experiences. This led me to create Abroad&Co. Each map is handcrafted, both from personal experience and local recommendations. They're a go-to way to learn what each new place you visit has to offer.
Whether it's to help plan a dream trip abroad or explore more of what your own backyard has to offer, check out my collection of ready-to-go maps or let me create one for yourself.
Feel free to reach out with any questions, additions, or corrections at (thomas.abroadandco@gmail.com).
Send A Tip
Support Tom Isbister’s work.
Select your tip amount
$5
$10
$20
$50
Or type in other amount
Explore related destinations
Read more about places in this guide
Powered by Thatch
The home for unique & authentic travel
The home for unique & authentic travel
Powered by Thatch: Where great trips are made.
© Tom Isbister 2024 • Help • Privacy • Terms • Copyright • Become a Seller • Seller Academy • About • Careers • Blog • Explore Places