The Best Cookies in New York
Save for Later
Share
The Best Cookies in New York
Perfect Little Planet
We have visited over 25 bakeries (and eaten well over that amount in cookies) to bring you this guide to the best cookies that NYC has to offer. You probably know about Levain, Insomnia, and maybe even City Cakes, but what about the small bakeries or cafes that have a killer cookie on the menu? And what to eat at each one? This guide will tell you where to go and what to order so you can make this visit to New York the most delicious trip of your life. 🤤
Includes:
🍪15 bakeries with our favorite cookies from each
đź“ťA little background and fun stories about each bakery
For about the price of a Levain cookie, you can save yourself lots of research time, and save your tastebuds from trying Instagram favorite cookies that look amazing but only taste "ok." All the cookies in this list are so good, they're worth coming to New York specifically to eat them.
Why should you trust us? Because we LOVE cookies. Our video of the best cookies in New York has been seen over 200k times, and the comments support our choices. Because cookie shops are constantly opening and closing, the YouTube video is already outdated. This guide will be constantly updated when new contenders for best cookie in New York comes on the scene.
Enjoy!!
Updated ago
16
Share
The Best Cookies in New York
You can't go wrong with any cookies on this list, and we encourage you to eat them all, but if you can only hit a few on your trip, definitely check out Levain and Janie's. Those are hands down our favorites.
Levain
Levain Bakery - 74th Street
@perfectlittleplanet
Levain is one of the most well-known bakeries and cookie shops in NYC and it deserves it's reputation. These 6 oz. cookies do not disappoint.
Levain has multiple locations throughout Manhattan, but if you want to visit the original location, head to the 74th street location. There is no seating here and often a line out the door because of the shops miniature size!
WHAT TO ORDER:
To be honest, you can't go wrong with any of the staples:
- Chocolate chip walnut
- Two chip chocolate chip
- Dark chocolate peanut butter chip (favorite of ours)
- Oatmeal raisin (favorite of ours)
- Dark chocolate chocolate chip
Levain has started to offer a seasonal cookie, which are good in their own right, but the classic selection above are home runs every time, no question.
INSIDER TIP:
The name of the bakery is often mispronounced for how it's spelled, but is actually pronounced "Luh-ven". We're stuck in our ways over here though and can't see us changing our pronunciation any time soon!
Add to
Details
Janie's Life Changing Baked Goods
Janie's Life-Changing Baked Goods
@perfectlittleplanet
UWS location.
Not only is Janie's story a good one (read here: https://janiebakes.com/pages/about), but the cookies are out of this world! You will not find another cookie like this. It borders between pie and cookie in the best way possible. The staff are the sweetest people you will ever meet and can help you narrow down your cookie choice because you will want one of everything.
WHAT TO ORDER:
Don't skip the pie crust cookies! Get whatever flavor you are feeling—they're all delicious!
If you want to grab a regular cookie too, they are also good. But I repeat: Do not skip the pie crust cookies!
INSIDER TIP:
The UWS location does not offer indoor seating, but does have outdoor seating. Come prepared for the weather whatever that may be.
Add to
Details
Janie's Life Changing Baked Goods
@perfectlittleplanet
UES location.
Not only is Janie's story a good one (read here: https://janiebakes.com/pages/about), but the cookies are out of this world! You will not find another cookie like this. It borders between pie and cookie in the best way possible. The staff are the sweetest people you will ever meet and can help you narrow down your cookie choice because you will want one of everything.
WHAT TO ORDER:
Don't skip the pie crust cookies! Get whatever flavor you are feeling—they're all delicious!
If you want to grab a regular cookie too, they are also good. But I repeat: Do not skip the pie crust cookies!
INSIDER TIP:
The UES has very limited indoor space, so plan on taking your cookies to-go.
Add to
Details
Buy to unlock full guide
Access all the local insights and recommendations from @perfectlittleplanet when you purchase this guide.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Perfect Little Planet
We are Brian and Isa. We share our experiences with you so you can feel confident when you visit.
Our YouTube videos have amassed millions of views, and we've helped thousands in our community of over 40k subscribers know where to go, what to do, and how to do it.
What's included
Digital Map
Fully interactive, digital map for finding places nearby
19 places
19 hand-picked places with notes from the creator
1 link
1 link from the creator to go even deeper with more info
DESTINATION(S) COVERED
New York, NY, USA
FOCUSES AND THEMES
Foodie
Format
DIY Tour
Self-guided tours are self-paced, stop-by-stop experiences like a food crawls or history walks.
COMMON QUESTIONS
What is Thatch?
Thatch is an online marketplace that provides instant access to thousands of vetted local experts and premium travel guides - making it the easiest and most affordable way to take high quality trips with less stress.
For travel creators (tastemakers, travel advisors, influencers and local experts) Thatch makes it easy to curate, publish, and sell digital travel guides, itineraries and personalized planning services.
What if I’m not satisfied with my purchase?
How do I access my purchased guides?
Can I access my guide offline?
How often are guides updated?
Can I request a personalized guide or itinerary?
Can I sell my own travel guides and itineraries?
Save for Later
Share
